Osteopathic manipulative treatment had small effect on low back pain
Published results showed standard osteopathic manipulative treatment for nonspecific subacute or chronic low back pain had a small effect on low back pain-specific activity limitations compared with sham osteopathic manipulative treatment.
Christelle Nguyen, MD, PhD, and colleagues randomly assigned 400 participants with nonspecific subacute or chronic low back pain to receive either 6 weeks of standard osteopathic manipulative treatment (OMT; n=200) or sham OMT (n=200) delivered by non-physician, non-physiotherapist osteopathic practitioners. Researchers used the self-administered Quebec Back Pain Disability Index to measure mean reduction in low back pain-specific activity limitations at 3 months as the primary end point. Secondary outcomes included mean reduction in low back pain-specific activity limitations, mean changes in pain and health-related quality of life, number and duration of sick leave, as well as number of low back pain episodes at 12 months, and consumption of analgesics and NSAIDs at 3 and 12 months. Researchers also collected self-reported adverse events at 3, 6 and 12 months.
Among the 197 participants analyzed in each group, results showed a mean duration of current low back pain episode of 7.5 months. Researchers found mean Quebec Back Pain Disability Index scores of 31.5 at baseline and 25.3 at 3 months in the standard OMT group vs. 27.2 at baseline and 26.1 at 3 months in the sham OMT group. Participants who received standard OMT had a mean reduction in low back pain-specific activity limitations of –4.7 at 3 months vs. –1.3 in the sham OMT group, results showed. Researchers found a mean difference in mean reduction in low back pain-specific activity limitations of –4.3 at 12 months, as well as a mean difference in mean reduction in pain of –1 at 3 and 12 months. Participants had no statistically significant differences in other secondary outcomes, according to researchers. Results showed participants in the standard and sham OMT groups self-reported four and eight serious adverse events, respectively, although none were considered related to OMT.
“Osteopathic manipulative treatment has a small, but likely not clinically meaningful, effect on low back pain-specific activity limitations vs. sham treatment at 3 and 12 months. We found no evidence of effect on pain and health-related quality of life,” Nguyen told Healio Orthopedics. “Our results question the usefulness of osteopathic manipulative treatment in people with nonspecific subacute and chronic low back pain.”
Collapse
Read more about