September 11, 2017
1 min read
Save

Better arc of motion found with screw vs staple fixation of the wrist

You've successfully added to your alerts. You will receive an email when new content is published.

Click Here to Manage Email Alerts

We were unable to process your request. Please try again later. If you continue to have this issue please contact customerservice@slackinc.com.

Logan McGinn
SAN FRANCISCO — Although there are various methods of fixation available for four-corner fusion of the wrist, results presented here showed inconsistent functional outcomes, union rates and complication rates among these methods.

Logan McGinn, MD, performed a retrospective review of data for 64 patients who underwent either headless compression screw fixation (n=38) or staple fixation (n=26) for treatment of scaphoid lunate advanced collapse (SLAC) or scaphoid nonunion advanced collapse (SNAC).

“The primary functional outcomes included pre- vs. postoperative flexion extension, arc of motion and grip strength,” McGinn said in her presentation. “Secondary outcomes were complications and fusion rates.”

Results showed an overall postoperative decreased range of motion in both groups, with an average loss of 9.2° in the screw group and of 27.9° in the staple group. However, McGinn noted the loss of range of motion was only statistically significant in the screw group.

“Our data showed, on average, the screw group’s flexion extension range of motion had improved postoperatively by 8%, whereas the staple group consistently lost range as expected,” she said.

Patients who underwent staple fixation experienced immobilization on average 21 days longer vs. the screw fixation group, according to McGinn.

“All patients went on to union in the screw group compared to only 88.5% in the staple group,” McGinn said. “The time to union on average was 6 weeks longer in patients treated with staples.”

McGinn noted the staple group had a statistically significant higher complication rate at 50% vs. 13.2% in the screw group, which also led to a higher reoperation rate of 38.6% in the staple group compared with 7.9% in the screw group. – by Casey Tingle

 

Reference:

McGinn L. Paper #24. Presented at: American Society for Surgery of the Hand Annual Meeting; Sept. 7-9, 2017; San Francisco.

Disclosure: McGinn reports that she has no relevant financial disclosures.